Reloading: An Even ‘Holier’ Consideration!
- By Wheelwrite
-
57
Comments
- Last updated: 08/12/2016
As a self-confessed ammo anorak, I spend time on the interweb searching for quality research papers on my pet subject. A multitude of productive sources include declassified documents from various elements of the U.S. Military, including the American Department of the Army for Research, Development and Acquisition Library in Washington. The later, more technical material from the U.S. Army Research Laboratory at Aberdeen Proving Ground (APG) in Maryland, as well as the Close Combat Armaments Center, Picatinny Arsenal, New Jersey.
Which leads me to the issue of terminology. I think G B Shaw got it right - (sic) “two nations divided by a common language”. For some years I’ve ignored papers that made reference to a spit-hole’, especially after a quick Google revealed some VERY strange images! Silly me. The U.S. Military, including John J Ritter of Aberdeen Proving Ground, uses the term to describe a cartridge flash hole. So here we are again, a year or so later and with more information on the topic of flash (spit) holes, thanks to John Ritter.
A flash hole allows the flame and pressure wave from the detonated primer to penetrate the propellant charge. The diameter needs to be small enough to stop the propellant charge from migrating into the primer cavity and large enough to prevent back pressure from rupturing the primer cup or blowing it to shreds. Standard SAAMI, CIP and case manufacturers data gives little clues as to the most desirable dimensions. Various web forums and sites refer to SAAMI dimensions but I’m not convinced, the nearest to a consensus indicating a range of .078” to .082”. Some unattributed drawings quote a nominal industry ‘standard’ diameter of .080” with a tolerance of +.004”, -.000”. There are also ‘Match’ cases, including Lapua PPC, BR, and 6.5x47 Lapua, which are produced with flash holes of .060” nominal diameter.
Additionally, some other European brass has flash hole diameters in the range of .063” to .067”. Oh yes, there’s also the unique (to UK S1 shooters) flash hole of the .50 BMG. My last resort was to collect and measure as many sample cases as possible. Indeed, my Lapua BMG brass measures .138” to.140”. If you’re buying uniforming tools it therefore makes sense to take some prior measurements!
Ritter’s work was in part provoked by an earlier Picatinny Arsenal study, “7.62-mm PRIMER/ PROPELLANT INTERFACE STUDY” by Mahmoud David Ahmad, into delayed ignition issues with M34 primers in pre-1993 Lake City Army Ammunition Plant (LCAAP) M80 ball ammo, the results of the work were illustrated by ignition and pressure timing curves and the issues traced in part to the primer sensitizing compound, tetracene, as well as to cartridge construction anomalies. Whilst these nominal hang-fire (0.3 to 0.4 millisecond) primer delays had been tolerable in gas-operated weapons, they had serious implications on the timing functions of the M134 electric minigun.
The work went on to compare performance with crimped and un-crimped rounds, variations in bullet seating depth and changes from the standard WC846 ball propellant. One of the notable conclusions was the intimate relationship between primer detonation effects and the propellant design – a proposed change to a flash suppressed version of the M80 propellant charge, WC846FS was the outcome. It had a faster burning rate, with similar density but the changed chemistry gave much more reliable primer/propellant ignition interaction. The pressure/time curves and spikes recorded between the new and old propellant designs were significantly different. It partly explains why ‘surplus’ canister WC846 is now readily available to the American handloader!
As a prelude to his new research, Ritter had also investigated primer timing and pressure issues in his previous work with #34 primers in 7.62 M80 ball:- “Spit-Hole Effects on the Ballistics of a 7.62-mm Cartridge”. Here he was using the WC846 based M80 cartridges as the default, with M80 ‘A’ variants using the WC846FS. This was his first published work with the use of a reduced flash hole diameter, down from .078” to .055”, equating to a 50% reduction in area. In the ‘primer-only’ evaluations he recorded a 20 fold increase in primer pocket pressure from the reduced flash hole and concluded that this was potentially disruptive.
When the experiment was repeated using fully assembled cartridges, the samples with the reduced flash hole produced a 350% increase in primer pocket pressure over those with the standard flash hole. In each test, the bullets in rounds employing the reduced flash hole diameter reached the engraving point faster than in the standard rounds, pointing to an accelerated deflagration profile. Since the ‘speed’ of the propellant was the same, it has to be concluded that the increased primer pressure spike achieve a faster breakdown of the ball powder retardants and initiated deflagration throughout the charge in a shorter time. Interestingly, whilst muzzle velocities were almost the same, the SD for the rounds with the reduced flash hole reduced by an amazing 30%. It seems that the Palma Match principle is a good one! Again, his tests revealed ignition inconsistencies with the ‘standard’ WC 846 propellant.
In this latest work, “Influence of Berdan and Boxer Primer Spit-Hole Diameter on 7.62-mm Cartridge Performance” he embraced the concept of Berdan flash holes. Here we have the combined performance of two of them to consider, from both a dynamic and dimensional point of view. He was again working with the 7.62mm M80 military cartridge. He used un-punched Lake City year 12 contract brass to simulate the Berdan effect, drilling two slightly offset holes, each of .055” diameter. The sum hole area being identical to that of a single ‘standard’ 7.62mm LC Boxer of .078” diameter – namely .0048 square inches. In a move not unlike my original experiments, he then produced a third batch with an oversize single flash hole of .110” diameter or .0095 square inches – approx twice the area of those in the other two batches.
The three test cartridge designs were all fitted with No. 34 Boxer primers (LCAAP NATO Spec #34) from the same production batch (LC- 08E720-252). Care was taken to ensure that none of the three anvil legs obscured the two ‘Berdan’ flash holes. Projectiles and propellant were from single batches and reflected the then service recipe which by now used WC846FS. The size of each batch was surprisingly small, just eight rounds. It is interesting to compare these results with those from his earlier work.
Here the variations in pressure and performance were marginal. However, Ritter did record that the slight difference noted showed that “the Berdan style spit-hole produces pressure sooner in the IB cycle, but that pressure has a lower pressurization rate (more gradual slope) and a lower peak pressure than the (standard) M80 (49.8 ksi versus 50.6 ksi). All of this translates into a slightly diminished muzzle velocity. If there is one area that the Berdan-style primer may outperform the standard M80, it is with its consistency. The standard deviation of both the muzzle velocity and peak pressure was lower in the Berdan. However, none of the configurations explored had particularly bad standard deviations.”
These experiments seem to illustrate that the ‘standard’ flash hole diameter is a safe, practical dimension, fit for purpose; and that progressive increases in the surface area have an increasingly deleterious effect on cartridge performance, whilst progressive reductions in surface area cause increased pressure and accelerated deflagration for a given type and size of charge. Although not a commercially viable proposition, the tests also hint that the ‘two hole’ Berdan principle can improve regularity and reduce performance SD. Of equal interest is the close relationship between these changes and the behaviours of particular propellants.
Influence of Berdan and Boxer Primer Spit-Hole Diameter on 7.62-mm Cartridge Performance, John J. Ritter. Weapons and Materials Research Directorate, ARL, Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD 21005-5066. Unclassified doc. ARL-TR-6968 June 2014 Spit-Hole Effects on the Ballistics of a 7.62-mm Cartridge, John J. Ritter. Weapons and Materials Research Directorate, ARL, Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD 21005-5066. Unclassified doc. ARL-TR-6785 February 2014
7.62-mm PRIMER/PROPELLANT INTERFACE STUDY, Mahmoud David Ahmad. U.S. Army Research, Development and Engineering Center. Close Combat Armaments Center, Picatinny Arsenal, New Jersey. Unclassified doc. ARCCD-TR-97010 March 1998
57 Comments
metronidazole 400mg ca <a href="https://augmentiln.com/">augmentin 1000mg us</a> cost glucophage 1000mg
Sspyyz
10 Aug 2022 at 05:07 PMcheap cialis <a href="https://sildenedpill.com/">viagra next day</a> viagra mail order
Ztwyyj
08 Aug 2022 at 04:27 AMondansetron 8mg without prescription propecia cheap
Vxbezl
05 Aug 2022 at 02:34 AMcost zantac 300mg <a href="https://zantasp.com/">zantac 150mg cheap</a> tamsulosin online order
Kkzlus
03 Aug 2022 at 08:04 PMbuy cialis 40mg for sale <a href="https://tadalcialsl.com/">cialis 5mg pill</a> avodart online order
Cmregj
02 Aug 2022 at 01:22 PMesomeprazole 40mg price <a href="https://sidenafilppl.com/">sildenafil 25 mg</a> cialis tadalafil 40mg
Tmqdsw
01 Aug 2022 at 06:25 AMorder sildalis online <a href="https://estracpl.com/">estradiol 1mg uk</a> purchase losartan pills
Pxvjya
30 Jul 2022 at 11:03 PMisotretinoin 20mg ca <a href="https://aurograpl.com/">purchase aurogra for sale</a> buy aurogra 100mg without prescription
Vdjbkh
29 Jul 2022 at 11:38 AMbuy sildenafil 150mg generic <a href="https://prednisols.com/">cost deltasone</a> buy deltasone 40mg for sale
Fpcgnj
28 Jul 2022 at 04:12 AMmethotrexate over the counter <a href="https://warfariny.com/">order generic warfarin 5mg</a> order reglan without prescription
Xfvhoe
26 Jul 2022 at 08:30 PMbuy flexeril 15mg sale <a href="https://ketorolacbuy.com/">ketorolac for sale</a> clopidogrel medication
Hoobpz
25 Jul 2022 at 09:52 AMezetimibe order online <a href="https://edbestplls.com/">best ed medication</a> motilium 10mg oral
Iyuhsn
23 Jul 2022 at 08:57 PMorder viagra 50mg without prescription <a href="https://rosuvastans.com/">buy crestor 10mg sale</a> cialis dosage 40 mg
Gopdor
21 Jul 2022 at 11:23 PMbuy priligy online cheap <a href="https://priligx.com/">brand dapoxetine 90mg</a> allopurinol online buy
Gslsgi
20 Jul 2022 at 06:19 PMorder baricitinib sale - <a href="https://amlodipinef.com/">buy norvasc 5mg</a> lisinopril cost
Gekivb
18 Jul 2022 at 09:49 AMorder generic hydroxychloroquine 400mg - <a href="https://tadalaficial.com/">order cialis 5mg pills</a> purchase cenforce
Cxzlxb
16 Jul 2022 at 03:38 AMneurontin 100mg cheap - <a href="https://dgabapentin.com/">neurontin 600mg generic</a> buy ivermectin 12mg online
Ayqong
14 Jul 2022 at 08:42 PMdeltasone for sale online - <a href="https://isotretinoint.com/">order accutane 10mg generic</a> order prednisolone pill
Gpkuns
13 Jul 2022 at 03:00 AMerection pills that work - <a href="https://sildende.com/">viagra 200mg kaufen ohne rezept</a> viagra kaufen für männer
Cbsjjo
11 Jul 2022 at 04:04 PMsildenafil 100mg tablet - <a href="https://fildenapl.com/">cost sildenafil</a> sildenafil cost
Bfemzu
10 Jul 2022 at 06:46 AMflagyl 400mg oral - <a href="https://cephalexinl.com/">purchase cephalexin for sale</a> cephalexin price
Tajmth
09 Jul 2022 at 02:23 AMorder finasteride 1mg for sale - <a href="https://finasterider.com/">order propecia 5mg online</a> order cipro 1000mg pill
Gepzxx
07 Jul 2022 at 06:41 PMcheap zofran 4mg - <a href="https://ondansetronr.com/">buy ondansetron 4mg generic</a> valtrex generic
Hjaqys
05 Jul 2022 at 08:50 AMhow much is cialis - <a href="https://rtamsulosin.com/">order generic tamsulosin 0.4mg</a> order generic tamsulosin
Zlkrud
02 Jul 2022 at 06:28 PMpurchase levofloxacin generic - <a href="https://viagplls.com/">viagra fast shipping</a> oral tadalafil 10mg
Wpmelg
01 Jul 2022 at 04:29 AMlosartan cost - <a href="https://topamaxn.com/">buy topiramate 200mg sale</a> order promethazine 25mg sale
Jzxnvb
29 Jun 2022 at 12:06 AMplavix uk - <a href="https://twarfarin.com/">order coumadin 2mg pill</a> metoclopramide drug
Tivufs
27 Jun 2022 at 07:05 AMpurchase flexeril for sale - <a href="https://rketorolac.com/">ketorolac for sale</a> inderal 10mg pills
Tmofba
25 Jun 2022 at 01:36 PMcost isotretinoin 40mg - <a href="https://risotretinoin.com/">order generic accutane 40mg</a> buy generic tetracycline 250mg
Uzyyax
23 Jun 2022 at 09:01 PMbuy generic modafinil 200mg - <a href="https://rbudesonide.com/">budesonide pill</a> rhinocort over the counter
Raqbki
22 Jun 2022 at 02:46 AMpfizer viagra 50mg - <a href="https://rtadalafil.store/">buy cialis 10mg without prescription</a> order cialis 10mg generic
Fnmfrr
20 Jun 2022 at 03:06 PMorder cenforce 100mg sale - <a href="https://xezetimibe.com/">buy zetia 10mg generic</a> motilium 10mg without prescription
Zzxsmu
19 Jun 2022 at 05:33 AMprednisone tablet - <a href="https://prednisoneix.com/">buy prednisone no prescription</a> order amoxicillin 1000mg pill
Hptjxp
16 Jun 2022 at 01:18 AMtadalafil 5mg sale - <a href="https://edtadalsfil.com/">buy tadalafil pills</a> buy viagra 50mg pills
Ragfbg
14 Jun 2022 at 05:12 AMlevothyroxine over the counter - <a href="https://desloratadi.store/">order desloratadine 5mg pill</a> order hydroxychloroquine 400mg
Nlwoyu
12 Jun 2022 at 05:33 PMalbuterol online - <a href="https://xdapoxetine.com/">order dapoxetine 90mg</a> buy priligy 90mg sale
Bwpzud
11 Jun 2022 at 05:51 AMbuy vardenafil pills - <a href="https://vardenafilxp.com/">buy vardenafil 20mg online cheap</a> order clomid 50mg without prescription
Oqrwth
09 Jun 2022 at 02:18 PMbrand lisinopril 5mg - <a href="https://omeprazolepx.com/">buy prilosec 20mg without prescription</a> order atenolol online
Jkmlgl
08 Jun 2022 at 02:53 AMbuy metformin 1000mg sale - <a href="https://metforminx.store/">generic metformin 500mg</a> purchase norvasc without prescription
Kklbio
06 Jun 2022 at 01:21 PMplaquenil 200mg us - <a href="https://baricitinib.store/">buy baricitinib 2mg sale</a> order generic baricitinib 2mg
Gftliq
05 Jun 2022 at 12:01 AMlasix 40mg brand - <a href="https://furosemideg.com/">lasix 40mg oral</a> ivermectin 3mg dosage
Joohhk
03 Jun 2022 at 08:22 AMorder prednisolone 10mg without prescription - <a href="https://neurontinx.store/">order gabapentin 600mg sale</a> buy sildenafil 100mg
Bmlgjk
01 Jun 2022 at 04:28 PMamoxicillin 500mg price - <a href="https://azithromycpl.com/">azithromycin generic</a> brand viagra
Fgufde
31 May 2022 at 04:26 AMprednisone 5mg over the counter - <a href="https://edpill.store/">buy ed pills fda</a> accutane 40mg sale
Vjgems
29 May 2022 at 07:27 PMbuy cialis 10mg for sale - <a href="https://provigpill.store/">modafinil 100mg for sale</a> purchase modafinil pills
Euworq
28 May 2022 at 10:16 AMbuy doxycycline 100mg pill - <a href="https://clomidg.store/">clomiphene 50mg pills</a> cialis 40mg oral
Gtdohg
26 May 2022 at 01:24 PMamoxil 500mg tablet - <a href="https://zithromycinc.store/">buy azithromycin 500mg online cheap</a> levitra 10mg cost
Rykutk
23 May 2022 at 01:35 PMacillin generic - <a href="https://ampicillinc.store/">buy ampicillin generic</a> cost tadalafil 20mg
Dwktcv
21 May 2022 at 01:56 PMceftin price - <a href="https://xcialis.store/">purchase cialis online cheap</a> purchase tadalafil
Jpplvn
20 May 2022 at 02:57 AMorder rhinocort sale - <a href="https://xbudesonide.quest/">buy budesonide</a> disulfiram drug
Ifumar
18 May 2022 at 03:30 PMcephalexin 500mg pills - <a href="https://xerythromycin.store/">cost erythromycin</a> erythromycin 250mg tablet
Nbkuqm
15 May 2022 at 12:14 AMbactrim drug - <a href="https://xsildenafil.store/">viagra 50mg us</a> viagra 150mg without prescription
Tzmzyc
12 May 2022 at 04:11 PMorder augmentin 625mg online cheap - <a href="https://tadalcialis.store/">cialis usa</a> order tadalafil 40mg pills
Ecbvem
10 May 2022 at 03:31 AMprednisolone brand - <a href="https://cialisxb.store/">order cialis 10mg online cheap</a> cialis 5mg tablet
Cqquya
07 May 2022 at 04:31 PMviagra sildenafil 50mg - <a href="https://bestusasild.com/">buy viagra 50mg without prescription</a> over the counter viagra
Mcjghh
03 May 2022 at 11:48 AMReloading and emission are planned for the general course for the people. The availability of https://www.essaygeeks.co.uk/buy-assignment/ is rightly followed by the students. The volume is fit for the true way for the changes. The pattern is fit for the staled items for humans.
Kasey Tatum
07 May 2021 at 05:54 PMThank you for sharing this information, I will consider it carefully before using it!
https://miniroyale2.com
lindatvar
14 Apr 2020 at 10:47 AM