Icon Logo Gun Mart

17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire Ammunition

17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire Ammunition

The .22 rimfire will do you for 90% of your vermin control needs, but there are times when a flat-shooting hard hitting round is required, especially if you need to control foxes also. Here, the .17HMR (Hornady Magnum Rimfire) has carved a very nice niche for itself in the British vermin shooter’s arsenal; as it solves the problem of the curved trajectory of the .22LR but its fast, light bullet can cause massive carcass damage on rabbits and hares! Due to the dual role nature of this round for light skinned quarry, such as crows and rabbits or larger species such as hares and foxes, I wanted to see how four of the most popular makes actually performed when tested head to head. Armed with this data, hopefully you can choose which make, bullet weight and design suits your needs best. The newer 17 WSM and 17 Hornet are now making in-roads into the popularity of the HMR, but it still remains very popular!

Test regime

I used the tried and tested Ballistic Putty, which works very well for small calibre ammunition and gives a better indication of the bullet performance than the Ballistic Wax that I use for centrefire testing. I formed identical blocks of putty 10” long and 5” high and wide to allow the bullets to expand to their maximum, yet retain the wound channel and capture the fragments for analysis. Velocity and therefore muzzle energy was measured using a Chrony F-1 chronograph.

To ascertain the effectiveness of each bullet, the maximum penetration depth was measured, as was the terminal weight of the projectiles and of most importance was the total volume of the wound channel measured in millilitres (mls). The putty was set up at 50 yards and accuracy was tested at 100 using a CZ 455 Thumbhole 17 HMR rifle.

Ammunition tested

I chose four most common loads to test and reflect the differing bullet weights and styles available. Generally, 17-grain V-MAX bullets are the norm and designed to expand rapidly on soft skinned or furred vermin, such as crow and rabbits. I tested the Hornady Varmint load because this reflects other brands that also use essentially the same bullet, such as Winchester, Federal and Remington and in reality perform similarly.

Keeping with the 17-grain weight, the next up was the CCI TNT load that uses a Speer TNT hollow point, which is designed to perform much in the same way as the V-MAX. Upping the weight more, I chose the CCI Game Point, with its 20-grain load. Buildwise, it’s a protected soft tip with the open-nosed jacket contained the lead point, which has a dimple in it. It’s designed to expand more predictably, without disintegrating, as the V-MAX does! Being 3-grains heavier and perhaps slightly stronger in construction, meant that it would be better for larger vermin species, such as foxes, where you want deeper penetration before expansion.

Newest, and following the ethos of non-lead or lead free bullets, is the Hornady NTX (Non-Toxic) load. The bullet is lighter, at 15.5-grains, due to the lack of lead in its construction but it still has a plastic tip with sintered tin core and is designed to expand rapidly, like the V-MAX.

Analysis of results

Firstly, the CZ455 rifle shot some really tight groups, which made it easier to connect with the ballistic putty centrally for each shot. Accuracy-wise, groups were very consistent and tiny at 100 yards. The Hornady 17-grain V-MAX and CCI TNT loads shot just over an inch, which is still very good for a rimfire, whilst the new Hornady NTX load grouped 5-shots into only 0.85” at the same range. Best groups went to the CCI Game Points, with their 20-grain JSPs grouping an average of 0.65”, which was superb!

story continues below...

Accuracy is crucial to ‘hit’ the target, but so is actual bullet performance when it gets there, which is the point of these tests. Starting with the bog standard Hornady 17-grain V-MAX at 2593 fps velocity, this penetrated the least, at 4”, which can be a good thing, i.e. all the energy is dissipated into a small area quickly. Conversely, it may mean that on a heavier skinned animal than a rabbit, say a fox, it may not penetrate sufficiently at certain ranges. I have found that they are fine on foxes in reality, if bullet placement is correct. The wound channel was the third largest in size at 322ml, and as expected, the light, frangible V-MAX turned to shrapnel and I could only pick out 7.6-grains to weigh.

Good figures, bad accuracy

Second up was the 17-grain, CCI TNT, which at a velocity of 2657 fps penetrated a little further, at 4.5” inches, with a 310-ml wound channel. In real terms, not that different than the Hornady V-MAX, as the TNT too turned to shrapnel and only 7.2grains remained. But it had the highest velocity and energy figures, although it was also the least accurate in this rifle.

A nice surprise were the new lead-free offerings from Hornady, in the NTX, which uses a lighter bullet at 15.5-grains but actually did not have a velocity faster than the other bullets, as one might expect. At 2562 fps and generating 226 ft/lbs energy, it actually penetrated further than the V-Max and TNT bullet at 5.5” and then literally blew apart. A massive 496ml wound channel and bulged sides to the ballistic putty attested to the energy transfer and I could only find 5.8gr of bullet to weigh. It was also very accurate, nice load.

Finally, the 20-grain, CCI Game Point with the heaviest payload designed to penetrate deeper for fox-sized game. As one would expect, it was the slowest but still managed to produce 263 ft/lbs of energy, second highest. The extra momentum from the heavier jacketed soft tip bullet did indeed penetrate deeper at 6.75” and developed an enormous 592ml wound channel. The bullet had mushroomed perfectly to nearly twice its size and still retained 19.8-grains weight. Not only that, it was the most accurate at 0.65”, so a long-range, deep-penetrating load this one!

Conclusion

Any one of these loads will harvest vermin and it’s important that accuracy, although good in this CZ, may in other rifles be completely different. However, what will be the same is the terminal effects of each bullet type at the velocities stated. Both the Hornady V-MAX and CCI TNT 17-grains are fine for general vermin work and it will be down to cost of ammo and availability, which is probably the defining difference. The Hornady NTX 15.5gr was a really nice surprise, as I personally am not keen on lead-free bullets in my centrefire rifles but I have to say it was very accurate and gave a very impressive wound channel.

However, speaking to the Editor Pete Moore about the NTX, which he tested a few years ago, he reckoned on rabbits and hares he was getting a lot of shootthroughs with no expansion on chest shots, at close to medium ranges 50 to 120-yards. Animals ran to die up to 50-80 yards away, where they would have dropped on the spot with a V-MAX, Game Point or TNT. In his words: “accurate yes, but best for head shots!”

The CCI Game Points were superb both in energy generated, superb accuracy from the CZ and overall penetration and maximum wound channel results. You may say well why do I not just shoot theses and no other? These would be excellent for larger vermin but might over penetrate on a rabbit, whereas a more frangible bullet like the V-MAX or TNT turns to shrapnel and so reduces the risk of ricochets. I know that due to the demand for .17 HMR that some of the quality control has been a bit iffy, with split cases and even no powder, so try a few boxes and if you like it, then buy a quantity of that batch number for consistent results. The choice, they say, is up to you.

 

  • 17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire Ammunition - image {image:count}

    click on image to enlarge

  • 17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire Ammunition - image {image:count}

    click on image to enlarge

  • 17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire Ammunition - image {image:count}

    click on image to enlarge

  • 17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire Ammunition - image {image:count}

    click on image to enlarge

  • 17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire Ammunition - image {image:count}

    click on image to enlarge

  • 17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire Ammunition - image {image:count}

    click on image to enlarge

gun
features

  • Contact: CCI, Federal GMK Ltd, 01489 579999 Hornady Edgar Brothers, 01625 613177 Winchester BWM IS Brands, 01235 514550

57 Comments

  • azithromycin 500mg generic <a href="https://metformil.com/">order glucophage 500mg online cheap</a> metformin 500mg over the counter

    Default profile image
    Ehvogj
    08 Aug 2022 at 08:08 PM
  • tadalafil cost <a href="https://tadalaedpill.com/">cialis 20mg generic</a> sildenafil 150mg ca

    Default profile image
    Ixbqbj
    07 Aug 2022 at 01:46 PM
  • oral diflucan 100mg <a href="https://diflucansx.com/">buy fluconazole 100mg generic</a> sildenafil uk

    Default profile image
    Hzlyzp
    06 Aug 2022 at 07:22 AM
  • zofran us finasteride 5mg for sale

    Default profile image
    Nidmjf
    04 Aug 2022 at 11:50 AM
  • zantac online <a href="https://celecoxibp.com/">purchase celebrex pills</a> tamsulosin 0.2mg over the counter

    Default profile image
    Wrjond
    03 Aug 2022 at 05:16 AM
  • cialis 5mg us <a href="https://levofloxacinl.com/">order levofloxacin 500mg for sale</a> avodart medication

    Default profile image
    Dwkvud
    01 Aug 2022 at 10:36 PM
  • esomeprazole pills <a href="https://tadalafilspl.com/">cialis canada</a> buy cialis 20mg online cheap

    Default profile image
    Lfrmua
    31 Jul 2022 at 03:27 PM
  • sildenafil pills 200mg <a href="https://lamotriginep.com/">lamictal pills</a> losartan for sale online

    Default profile image
    Jpvukt
    30 Jul 2022 at 07:54 AM
  • isotretinoin 40mg pill <a href="https://suhagrapls.com/">purchase suhagra without prescription</a> sildenafil 50mg drug

    Default profile image
    Kaqvmy
    28 Jul 2022 at 08:30 PM
  • buy sildenafil 50mg pills <a href="https://prednisols.com/">cheap prednisone 20mg</a> deltasone 20mg oral

    Default profile image
    Uzryln
    27 Jul 2022 at 12:56 PM
  • methotrexate over the counter <a href="https://metoclopramy.com/">brand metoclopramide</a> order reglan online

    Default profile image
    Zgvxqf
    26 Jul 2022 at 05:01 AM
  • flexeril tablet <a href="https://colchicinbuy.com/">order colchicine online</a> cost plavix 150mg

    Default profile image
    Powwsl
    24 Jul 2022 at 07:42 PM
  • zetia 10mg cost <a href="https://tetracyclinbuy.com/">order tetracycline 500mg generic</a> purchase domperidone generic

    Default profile image
    Phnrdl
    23 Jul 2022 at 06:43 AM
  • buy viagra online cheap <a href="https://edsildenp.com/">usa viagra sales</a> cialis usa

    Default profile image
    Mwwxkn
    21 Jul 2022 at 09:15 AM
  • generic baricitinib 2mg - <a href="https://metforminf.com/">cost glucophage</a> lisinopril 5mg us

    Default profile image
    Pvbetb
    17 Jul 2022 at 08:32 PM
  • order hydroxychloroquine 400mg - <a href="https://hydroxyne.com/">hydroxychloroquine 400mg cost</a> cenforce for sale online

    Default profile image
    Aeunqx
    16 Jul 2022 at 06:46 PM
  • oral neurontin 800mg - <a href="https://gdoxycycline.com/">stromectol 12mg ca</a> ivermectin 4 tablets price

    Default profile image
    Dqqxbu
    15 Jul 2022 at 10:42 AM
  • prednisone for sale - <a href="https://dprednisolone.com/">prednisolone 40mg oral</a> order generic prednisolone 5mg

    Default profile image
    Wwyamg
    13 Jul 2022 at 08:12 PM
  • low cost ed pills - <a href="https://sildende.com/">sildenafil ohne rezept</a> sildenafil kaufen generika

    Default profile image
    Dsehcx
    12 Jul 2022 at 05:20 AM
  • buy fildena 100mg generic - <a href="https://trazodonel.com/">order generic trazodone 50mg</a> viagra ca

    Default profile image
    Fuyozx
    10 Jul 2022 at 06:47 PM
  • oral propecia - <a href="https://fluconazoler.com/">cheap diflucan 100mg</a> order ciprofloxacin 1000mg pills

    Default profile image
    Civzku
    08 Jul 2022 at 06:49 AM
  • zofran generic - <a href="https://simvastatinr.com/">zocor without prescription</a> valacyclovir over the counter

    Default profile image
    Fczcuw
    06 Jul 2022 at 10:03 AM
  • order cialis 20mg online - <a href="https://celecoxibr.com/">buy celebrex</a> purchase tamsulosin generic

    Default profile image
    Vnjqzl
    02 Jul 2022 at 03:35 PM
  • order levaquin 250mg online cheap - <a href="https://dutasterider.com/">purchase avodart without prescription</a> buy tadalafil 10mg pill

    Default profile image
    Dielut
    01 Jul 2022 at 01:31 AM
  • cozaar 50mg sale - <a href="https://losartann.com/">purchase cozaar pill</a> purchase promethazine generic

    Default profile image
    Riyjne
    28 Jun 2022 at 09:00 PM
  • clopidogrel order online - <a href="https://tmethotrexate.com/">purchase methotrexate online</a> buy metoclopramide 10mg for sale

    Default profile image
    Rtxnqh
    27 Jun 2022 at 03:56 AM
  • buy flexeril 15mg pills - <a href="https://rcyclobenzapri.com/">flexeril 15mg canada</a> order inderal pill

    Default profile image
    Rjcmol
    25 Jun 2022 at 10:20 AM
  • order generic accutane 10mg - <a href="https://razithromycin.com/">zithromax online</a> order tetracycline 500mg without prescription

    Default profile image
    Vojgiw
    23 Jun 2022 at 05:34 PM
  • buy provigil 100mg - <a href="https://rerectpill.com/">buy erection pills</a> rhinocort usa

    Default profile image
    Cqxhlm
    22 Jun 2022 at 12:02 AM
  • viagra for men over 50 - <a href="https://fsildenafil.store/">female viagra sildenafil</a> cialis 20mg cheap

    Default profile image
    Rqgdcg
    20 Jun 2022 at 12:26 PM
  • buy cenforce 50mg pill - <a href="https://xdomperidone.com/">domperidone 10mg over the counter</a> motilium for sale online

    Default profile image
    Dvnurl
    19 Jun 2022 at 02:48 AM
  • oral prednisone 20mg - <a href="https://prednisoneix.com/">prednisone 60 mg pills</a> amoxil 1000mg cheap

    Default profile image
    Mbryfz
    15 Jun 2022 at 10:50 PM
  • cialis coupons - <a href="https://edtadxs.com/">cialis 20mg drug</a> viagra 50mg

    Default profile image
    Ezjjaw
    14 Jun 2022 at 02:31 AM
  • order synthroid - <a href="https://chloroquinedi.com/">hydroxychloroquine 400mg over the counter</a> hydroxychloroquine 400mg without prescription

    Default profile image
    Nkjewd
    12 Jun 2022 at 02:46 PM
  • purchase albuterol online cheap - <a href="https://albuterola.store/">ventolin 2mg canada</a> buy dapoxetine 30mg generic

    Default profile image
    Ugrtlh
    11 Jun 2022 at 03:14 AM
  • order levitra 20mg generic - <a href="https://clomiphene.store/">purchase clomid</a> clomid 100mg cheap

    Default profile image
    Ovtbvs
    09 Jun 2022 at 11:17 AM
  • lisinopril order - <a href="https://metoprololpx.com/">buy lopressor 50mg pill</a> buy tenormin 50mg online

    Default profile image
    Iplqox
    08 Jun 2022 at 12:07 AM
  • order generic metformin 1000mg - <a href="https://amlodipine.store/">amlodipine 5mg usa</a> amlodipine 10mg ca

    Default profile image
    Xhxuud
    06 Jun 2022 at 10:31 AM
  • plaquenil 200mg price - <a href="https://chloroquins.com/">buy aralen online cheap</a> order baricitinib

    Default profile image
    Fljbin
    04 Jun 2022 at 08:56 PM
  • lasix 40mg drug - <a href="https://doxycyclinet.com/">doxycycline price</a> buy ivermectin for humans

    Default profile image
    Ekisdb
    03 Jun 2022 at 05:23 AM
  • purchase prednisolone pill - <a href="https://viagsildss.com/">viagra 50mg tablet</a> order viagra 50mg for sale

    Default profile image
    Feaugv
    01 Jun 2022 at 12:56 PM
  • cheap amoxil tablets - <a href="https://amoxill.store/">buy amoxicillin 250mg online</a> sildenafil australia

    Default profile image
    Aowtmf
    31 May 2022 at 01:53 AM
  • prednisone 10mg us - <a href="https://accutanpll.com/">buy accutane 20mg</a> order isotretinoin generic

    Default profile image
    Iviiwq
    29 May 2022 at 04:54 PM
  • cost tadalafil 40mg - <a href="https://provigpill.store/">order provigil 100mg</a> buy modafinil 200mg generic

    Default profile image
    Ildtza
    28 May 2022 at 07:42 AM
  • buy doxycycline pill - <a href="https://edponlines.com/">brand cialis 10mg</a> cialis without prescription

    Default profile image
    Qewgal
    26 May 2022 at 10:31 AM
  • ivermectin 12 mg - <a href="https://vardenafilxn.store/">generic levitra 20mg</a> levitra 10mg price

    Default profile image
    Jmiquk
    24 May 2022 at 11:40 PM
  • oral amoxil 1000mg - <a href="https://zithromycinc.store/">purchase zithromax pills</a> buy vardenafil 10mg pills

    Default profile image
    Teoifh
    23 May 2022 at 10:46 AM
  • buy acillin sale - <a href="https://ciproflox.store/">ciprofloxacin uk</a> purchase cialis for sale

    Default profile image
    Khkiiz
    21 May 2022 at 11:15 AM
  • buy cefuroxime generic - <a href="https://robaxinx.store/">robaxin 500mg brand</a> oral cialis

    Default profile image
    Jyiurw
    20 May 2022 at 12:14 AM
  • rhinocort without prescription - <a href="https://xbudesonide.quest/">budesonide online buy</a> disulfiram 250mg cheap

    Default profile image
    Prvprc
    18 May 2022 at 12:39 PM
  • buy cephalexin 250mg online - <a href="https://xerythromycin.store/">brand erythromycin 250mg</a> erythromycin 250mg ca

    Default profile image
    Ovxvqw
    14 May 2022 at 06:07 PM
  • order bactrim 480mg pill - <a href="https://xviagrpill.today/">viagra 150mg cost</a> brand viagra 100mg

    Default profile image
    Jhlkzc
    12 May 2022 at 11:44 AM
  • augmentin pill - <a href="https://tadalcialis.store/">tadalafil 5mg cheap</a> generic cialis india

    Default profile image
    Xhizoj
    09 May 2022 at 10:22 PM
  • cheap prednisolone without prescription - <a href="https://prednisolonex.store/">brand prednisolone 40mg</a> cialis overnight

    Default profile image
    Gwpdcl
    07 May 2022 at 11:57 AM
  • order sildenafil 100mg without prescription - <a href="https://bestusasild.com/">sildenafil 150mg for sale</a> sildenafil 50mg canada

    Default profile image
    Hkoyqj
    04 May 2022 at 06:35 AM
  • Vehicle park creating is the best decision taken by the government.  I at the moment become the customary of the professional dissertation writing service in all the papers even in the mails. While going out many people are facing the problem of the parking and this will solve.

    Default profile image
    [email protected]
    21 Oct 2020 at 01:45 PM
  • Vehicle park creating is the best decision taken by the government.  I at the moment become the customary of the professional dissertation writing service in all the papers even in the mails. While going out many people are facing the problem of the parking and this will solve.

    Default profile image
    [email protected]
    21 Oct 2020 at 01:45 PM


Arrow